Man who called for help recounts witnessing deadly boat crash on Matanzas River

Crash Thursday night left 1 dead, 1 hospitalized

Jorge Carbato recounts hearing what proved to be a deadly boat crash Thursday night on the Matanzas River. (WJXT)

ST. AUGUSTINE, Fla. – A man who was on the Matanzas River in St. Augustine Thursday night and witnessed what proved to be a deadly boat crash shared his harrowing account with News4JAX.

Jorge Carbato said he called for help around 9:30 p.m. after hearing a boat slam into a piling between the Bridge of Lions and the 312 Bridge. The crash sent two people overboard.

Recommended Videos



Carbato said at first, he thought what he heard was a car crash on the Bridge of Lions.

“I heard a motor, and then I realized I didn’t hear the sound anymore. Within a few seconds, I started hearing someone calling for help. I called 911 immediately,” Carbato said.

RELATED: Body found in search for missing boater after St. Augustine boat crash, sources say

Carbato said he got on his boat and turned his spotlight on the crash scene. He saw wreckage among a couple of pilings in the water as the damaged boat’s lights sank below the surface.

After he spotted one of the boaters from the crash, Carbato said he kept his light on him until help arrived.

“I heard the guy yelling the whole time. I didn’t know there was another person on board,” Carbato said.

Florida Fish and Wildlife officials said one of the boaters was rescued from the water, but the other was found dead after a multi-agency search.

St. Johns Fire Rescue on the Matanzas River (WJXT)

Carbato said he visits Fish Island Marina in St. Augustine to go out on his boat almost every day. He said he knows how dangerous the water can be, and Thursday’s crash proved it.

“My condolences to the family and those involved,” Carbato said. “This is a very dark waterway. There’s a lot of curves or some congestion there. There’s a lot of traffic through here.”

The exact cause of the crash is still unknow, but the FWC says the investigation is still active.

The boater rescued from the water was taken to a hospital for treatment.


About the Authors

Chris Will has joined the News4JAX team as a weekend morning reporter, after graduating from the University of Florida in spring 2024. During his time in Gainesville, he covered a wide range of stories across the Sunshine State. His coverage of Hurricane Ian in southwest Florida earned a National Edward R. Murrow Award.

A Jacksonville native and proud University of North Florida alum, Francine Frazier has been with News4Jax since 2014 after spending nine years at The Florida Times-Union.

Recommended Videos